services






2 to 1 Americans Still Prefer Smaller Government - 11/14/08
Major Findings:
 
The majority of voters nationwide (53%) says they favor a smaller government with fewer services, while 28% favor a larger government with many services.  Although the preference for a smaller government has decreased slightly since 2006 (59%/28%), voters still favor a smaller government by a ratio of two to one.
 
Republican voters are more likely than Democratic voters to favor a smaller government.  The overwhelming majority of Republicans (78%/11%), McCain voters (80%/9%) and those who voted for the Republican candidate for U.S. Congress (79%/12%) favors a smaller government.  Conversely, a plurality of Democrats (33%/46%), Obama voters (29%/46%) and those who voted for the Democratic candidate for Congress (32%/44%) favors a larger government.  Among Independent voters, 54% favor a smaller government.
 
Six in ten white voters (61%) favor a smaller government, while half of African American voters (50%) favor a larger government.  Hispanic voters are evenly divided with 38% favoring a smaller government and 39% favoring a larger government.  Men (59%/26%), voters over age 55 (57%/21%) and those with savings of more than $5,000 (57%/26%) are more likely to prefer a smaller government than women (48%/31%), voters under age 55 (51%/34) and those with savings of less than $5,000 (47%/34%).
 
Would you say you most favor a smaller government with fewer services, or a larger government with many services?
 
Total
11/06
11/04
11/02
11/00
11/98
11/96
11/94
Smaller Government
53
59
49
61
58
63
63
68
Larger Government
28
28
37
27
28
28
26
21
DK/Refused
19
13
14
12
14
10
11
11
 
Region
New England
Middle Atlantic
East North Central
West North Central
South Atlantic
East South Central
West South Central
Mountain
Pacific
Smaller Government
41
45
53
61
51
60
66
57
52
Larger Government
35
38
29
21
29
22
21
28
26
DK/Refused
25
17
18
18
21
18
13
16
23
 

 
Party/Ideology
Rep.
Dem.
Ind.
Lib.
Mod.
Cons.
Smaller Government
78
33
54
25
46
78
Larger Government
11
46
22
57
29
12
DK/Refused
11
22
23
19
25
10
 
Vote for President/ Congress
McCain
Obama
Other
Rep. Congress
Dem. Congress
Other
Didn’t Vote
Smaller Government
80
29
66
79
32
73
51
Larger Government
9
46
8
12
44
8
11
DK/Refused
11
25
26
10
25
18
38
 
Race/Gender
White
African American
Hispanic
Men
Women
Smaller Government
61
24
38
59
48
Larger Government
23
50
39
26
31
DK/Refused
16
26
22
15
22
 
Income/Savings Over $5,000
Under $20,000
$20,000-$40,000
$40,000-$60,000
$60,000-$100,000
Over $100,000
Yes Savings
$5,000+
No Savings
$5,000+
Smaller Government
50
50
57
54
57
57
47
Larger Government
28
32
26
28
27
26
34
DK/Refused
23
18
17
18
16
17
19
 
Age
18-25
26-40
41-55
56-65
Over 65
Under 55
Over 55
Smaller Government
35
49
54
55
59
51
57
Larger Government
58
39
29
25
18
34
21
DK/Refused
7
13
18
20
23
15
22
 
Methodology:   
 
McLaughlin & Associates conducted a national post-election survey of 1,000 respondents who voted in the general election.  All interviews were conducted on November 4th, 2008 via telephone by professional interviewers.  Respondents were randomly selected within predetermined geographic units structured to correlate with actual voter turnout nationwide.  The survey of 1,000 respondents who voted in the general election has an accuracy of +/- 3.1% at a 95% confidence interval.